Estimate what violations really cost your fleet each year once fines, downtime and insurance impact are added together.
The real price of a violation
The roadside fine is only the first bill. An out-of-service order parks the truck and the load, towing may be needed, and every recorded violation feeds the FMCSA CSA system where it affects your safety scores for two to three years. Those scores influence insurance pricing, broker onboarding and shipper approval, which is why this calculator adds an insurance-impact line on top of the direct fines and downtime.
What fines look like in 2026
Under the FMCSA civil penalty schedule in 49 CFR Part 386 Appendix B, 2026 maximum penalties reach $19,246 per hours-of-service violation for motor carriers and $4,812 for drivers, with falsification of records carrying up to $15,846 per violation; the amounts adjust annually for inflation. Typical assessed penalties are far below the maximums (industry analyses put the average ELD-related HOS penalty near $2,900, the default used here), but a pattern of violations or an egregious case can multiply quickly.
Using the result
The total this calculator produces is effectively your compliance budget justification: if violations are costing five figures a year, spending on driver training, maintenance intervals, a better ELD or dash cameras usually pays for itself. Track your CSA scores through FMCSA's portal and rerun the numbers as they improve.
Sources