Rand McNally vs Garmin Fleet: User Reviews & Pricing 2025

Rand McNally and Garmin Fleet are two of the leading truck tracking companies.

But which one is better? And which one has the features you need?

Below we compare them based on user reviews, pricing (where available) and the range of fleet management features they both offer.

Rand McNally vs Garmin Fleet User Reviews

	Rand McNally	Garmin Fleet
Trustpilot Rating (out of 5)	3.1	No Rating
Number of Reviews	3	No Reviews
Websites:	Click To Visit The Rand McNally Website	Click To Visit The Garmin Fleet Website

All data was believed to be correct at the time of collection but may have since changed.

	Rand McNally	Garmin Fleet
Do they have iPhone App?	Yes, several	No
iPhone App Rating	1.7
Number of iPhone App Reviews	95
Do They have an Android App?	Yes, several	No
Android App Rating	2.6
Number of Android App Reviews	9

All data was believed to be correct at the time of collection but may have since changed.

	Rand McNally	Garmin Fleet
Do they offer a free trial?	Yes, one month of free subscription for your new fleet!	No
Starting Monthly Cost	Pricing Not Publicly Listed	Pricing Not Publicly Listed
Set-up / Hardware Cost	Pricing Not Publicly Listed	Pricing Not Publicly Listed

Data gathered from the Rand McNally and Garmin Fleet websites.

	Rand McNally	Garmin Fleet
ELD Solution	Yes	Yes
Dash Cam	Yes	No
GPS Fleet Tracking	Yes	No
Telematics	Yes	Yes
Asset Tracking	Yes	No
Compliance Managment	Yes	Yes
Driver Safety	Yes	Yes
Routing & Disptach	Yes	No
Maintenance	Yes	No
Reefer/Refrigerated Truck Monitoring	No	No
EV Solutions	No	No
Equipment Tracking	Yes	No
Trailer Tracking	Yes	No
Spend Management	No	No
Waste Reduction	No	No
IFTA Fuel Tax Reporting	Yes	No
Fuel Monitoring	Yes	No
Access Controls/Permissions	No	Yes
Alerts/Notifications	Yes	Yes
Cost Tracking	No	No
Employee Management	No	No
Geofencing	Yes	No
Incident Reporting	Yes	Yes
Mileage Tracking	Yes	No

Data gathered from the Rand McNally and Garmin Fleet websites.